Contents
Importance of Making Wills for Diocesan Priests
Conclusion: Preparing to leave well
Introduction
Today is the final post in my series after 280 consecutive weeks of publication every Monday morning, dating back to 5th July 2021. With today’s post, I have officially ended my weekly publication and will no longer publish on Mondays. All 281 posts are archived and are easily accessible on the existential theology website. I thank Chi di ebere for the wisdom and strength over these years.
Last week’s post proposed a template for an equitable overall income for priests that could reduce unhealthy competition and sycophancy among priests, improve fraternal relationships between bishops and priests, promote pastoral fruitfulness, and ultimately support the holistic salvation of souls.
Yet while the acquisition of temporal goods is topical among priests, what happens to those goods at death is rarely discussed. Even when unpleasant experiences arise regarding the disposal of diocesan priests’ property, there is no sustained discussion.
Against this backdrop, today’s post focuses on wills for diocesan priests. Canon law defers to civil law when it concerns wills (Can. 1299 §1; Can. 22). In civil law, a will is a document that declares one’s intention for what happens to one’s estate (the totality of one’s assets – real property, cash, investments, personal items minus debts and financial obligations) at death. I must state from the outset that I am not an expert in civil legal matters. My concern in this post is why it is opportune for diocesan priests to consider writing their wills.
The Right to a Will
Canon law recognises the freedom of those who are capable under natural law or canon law to dispose of their temporal goods by will (Can. 1299 §1). Canon law also recognises priests’ right to temporal goods. It encourages simplicity of life and refraining from all things that have a semblance of vanity, and encourages priests to use their surplus goods for the good of the Church and works of charity (Can. 282). Hence, priests have the right, under both natural law and canon law, to make a will.
The law is explicit regarding the temporal goods of priests who are members of institutes of consecrated life and societies of apostolic life. Can. 668 §1 reads: “Before first profession, members are to cede the administration of their goods to whomever they prefer and, unless the constitutions state otherwise, are to make disposition freely for their use and revenue. Moreover, at least before perpetual profession, they are to make a will which is to be valid also in civil law.” The disposition can be changed for a just cause and with the permission of the superior (Can. 668 §2).
However, the 1983 Code is silent regarding diocesan priests, allowing individual priests to decide if they consider it opportune. Regarding emeritus bishops, the Complementary Norms of the Catholic Bishops Conference of Nigeria on canon 402 §2 read: “Upon acceptance of his resignation by the Holy See, the bishop emeritus must put all his legal and financial affairs in order, and preferably make a new will, which will be recognised in civil law” (Catholic Bishops Conference of Nigeria, Particular Complementary Norms to the Revised Code, Lagos 1985, 11-12). This provision gives an insight into the disposition of the Church in Nigeria regarding wills for diocesan clergy.
Importance of Making Wills for Diocesan Priests
Although the Code of Canon Law is silent regarding wills for diocesan priests, it is important to state why having a will is opportune for diocesan priests in Nigeria.
The first reason is to differentiate between Church (ecclesiastical) goods and personal assets. Canon 1267 §1 reads: “Unless the contrary is established, offerings given to superiors or administrators of any ecclesiastical juridic person, even a private one, are presumed given to the juridic person itself”. As diocesan priests increasingly acquire personal goods that can be objectively established as such, they need to distinguish which goods belong to the Church and which belong to themselves.
A will can help the priest clarify what he actually owns as against Church property in his possession or entrusted to him for a particular ecclesial purpose.
Flowing from the first is the second reason: to help prevent disputes between the Church and the family, and between family members. Because Nigeria practices legal pluralism (the coexistence of different legal systems), inheritance law is pluralistic and governed by three distinct, overlapping legal systems: statutory, customary, and Islamic. The applicable rules depend on whether the person left a valid will (testate) or died without one (intestate), the nature of marriage, the property concerned, the relevant state law, and the applicable religious and customary law.
While celibate priests can inherit from their parents, they do not have dependents protected by law who must benefit from their goods if they die without a will (intestate). Yet, relatives or other entitled persons may still bring claims, depending on the relevant law. A valid will allows a priest, within the limits imposed by applicable law, to state his intentions regarding his estate.
Therefore, on the one hand, when a priest dies intestate, it may be difficult to know which goods belong to the Church and which belong to the priest. Hence, it is not sufficient for a priest to say that he has informed his bishop of his wishes or that his family knows what he wants. While these conversations can be sincere, they are not legally effective dispositions for a will. There have been instances where families wrongly accused the Church of taking their brother’s property.
Moreover, a priest dying intestate can cause disputes in his own family as family members fight over some of his belongings. There are also instances of this.
Without a will, disputes can arise between the Church and the family, and between family members, undermining the priest’s good work, the family’s disposition toward the Church, and ultimately harming the Church and her salvific mission.
The third reason is the loss of property to unintended institutions and individuals. If a priest writes a will, he will at least list his bank accounts, investments, and properties. At his death, it is easier for heirs to locate and access these assets. If he dies intestate, unintended people may take some of these properties, and his financial assets may become dormant, difficult to trace, or subject to regulatory procedures, especially when beneficiaries or executors are unaware of them. The next of kin listed for investments and bank accounts are alternative contacts for the financial relationship and do not necessarily equate to being a legal beneficiary or legal owner of an asset.
Fourth, a will can help a priest direct some of his goods for the good of the Church or for charitable purposes, as recommended by canon 282 §2 (Can. 1301 §1).
Preparing a will
As noted above, canon law defers to civil law regarding wills. In preparing a will, a priest should consider making an inventory of his bank accounts and savings, investments, vehicles, land or buildings that he personally owns, inherited property, valuable books and personal collections, electronic equipment, outstanding debts or obligations, insurance and other financial interests, personal items that have particular sentimental significance, and charitable or ecclesiastical causes he wishes to support. He should also consider where the relevant documents are kept and how the right people will know a will exists.
The will should be prepared and executed in accordance with Nigerian law. The applicable customary law may determine how some properties are disposed. Under customary law, some communities do not consider priests, by virtue of ordination, as eligible to inherit property. Hence, even though the priest might use it while alive, he does not determine what happens after his death.
For other assets governed by civil law, the will must be valid under civil law if the priest’s wishes for those assets are to be carried out and to reduce the risk of them passing to unintended parties. This is where subsidiarity-integrated centralisation helps, as it can enable dioceses to provide professional legal advice at scale to priests, especially when property is involved. This makes it important for dioceses to have civil lawyers who understand priests’ specific needs and their assets.
A will is of little use if no one can find it after the testator’s death. Hence, its safe custody is essential.
The written and sealed document may be deposited with the diocesan Chancellor (or directly to the bishop if preferred), the relevant Probate Registry, with a lawyer, a family member, or with another priest. One can also deposit it in several places at the same time, and can always update it at any time. However, if copies are kept in several places, it is important to ensure that the location of the original is known and that there is no confusion about the latest valid version.
Conclusion: Preparing to leave well
Discussion of wills remains unwelcome in Nigerian culture, and suggesting a will to diocesan priests is often seen as unnecessary or as a surreptitious way to learn their net worth, which could affect the bishop’s disposition toward his priests. The Dicastery for Legislative Texts affirms that the bishop is not to be held legally responsible for acts that concern the private life of priests, such as the administration of their assets, their home and social relationships (Pontifical Council for Legislative Texts, “VIII. Elements for configuring the scope of canonical responsibility of the diocesan Bishop with regard to the priests incardinated in his own diocese and who exercise their ministry there”, ( Communicationes, 36 [2004] 33–38), IV, a).
In the Church, the contents of a priest’s will and his private financial affairs should be treated with utmost confidentiality and respect for his right to privacy (Can. 220). Unauthorised tampering with the sealed will by the bishop or any curial official who may come across it infringes the priest’s right to privacy and, depending on the circumstances, may constitute an abuse of ecclesiastical office (Can. 1378 §1).
While some diocesan priests may be reluctant to make their wills, responsible stewardship of goods helps prevent situations that may arise at death. A priest does so by keeping appropriate records, separating his goods from those of the institution where he works, keeping records and documents safe, fulfilling financial obligations, and observing canon law and diocesan policy.
Yet, a change in orientation toward wills is opportune among diocesan priests. It should not be seen as a declaration of material possessions but as an act of stewardship: protecting legitimate interests, clarifying one’s intention regarding those assets, preventing conflict between the Church and family and between family members, and ensuring one’s intention regarding their goods is carried out. Pastoral stewardship is not only about how we acquire goods but also how we dispose of them when we conclude our earthly ministry.
Thank you for your attention over the past five years.
May God bless you🙏🏾
K’ọdị🙋🏾♂️